05242017Wed
Last updateTue, 23 May 2017 4pm

i

The Future of Coal: Efficiency Over Politics?

The Future of Coal: Efficiency Over Politics?

Many changes in the power industry have ...

Valve World Americas Event Set for June 20-21

Valve World Americas Event Set for June 20-21

End users, distributors, EPC/AEC personn...

Water Hammer

Water Hammer

Water hammer is a shock wave transmitted...

Turning the Tables on Valve Corrosion

Turning the Tables on Valve Corrosion

Multiple valve manufacturers and users w...

Subscribe vmspr17

FREE SUBSCRIPTION*

•  Print magazine
•  Digital magazine
•  VALVE eNews
Read the latest issue

*to qualified valve professionals in the U.S./Canada

The Weekly Report

New Products

  • ja-news-2
  • ja-news-3

Industry Headlines

Roger Fix Named Chairman of Flowserve

Tuesday, 23 May 2017  |  Chris Guy

In its most recent annual meeting, Flowserve announced that Bill Rusnack and Lynn Elsenhans have retired as members of the board of directors. Flowser...

Readmore

Loading...
Advertisement
i

Industry Headlines

Roger Fix Named Chairman of Flowserve

14 HOURS AGO

In its most recent annual meeting, Flowserve announced that Bill Rusnack and Lynn Elsenhans have retired as members of the board of directors. Flowserve also announced that board member Roger Fix has been elected to replace Rusnack as chairman.

"Bill and Lynn provided years of distinguished service to ...

Readmore

MRC Global Opening Gulf Coast Regional Distribution Center

1 DAY AGO

MRC Global (US) Inc. is opening a new regional distribution center (RDC) and operational hub for the Gulf Coast area in La Porte, TX. The new facility will house over 400,000 square feet of warehouse space, have over 75,000 square feet of office space and an extensive pipe yard. MRC Global expects t...

Readmore

ExxonMobil, SABIC Agree on Proposed Petrochemical Project

14 HOURS AGO

Affiliates of Exxon Mobil and SABIC (Saudi Basic Industries Corporation) signed an agreement to conduct a detailed study of the proposed Gulf Coast Growth Ventures project in Texas and begin planning for front-end engineering and design work. The agreement was signed during the Saudi-US CEO Forum in R...

Readmore

Report Shows Potential for Appalachian Petrochemical Industry

14 HOURS AGO

An economic report released by the American Chemistry Council (ACC) shows that the Appalachian region could become a second center of U.S. petrochemical and plastic resin manufacturing, similar to the Gulf Coast.

ACC's report presents a hypothetical scenario that includes the development of a storage ...

Readmore

ISM: Manufacturing Growth Should Continue Through 2017

16 HOURS AGO

According to the Institute for Supply Management (ISM), 64% of respondents from the panel of manufacturing supply management executives predict their revenues will be 8.5% greater in 2017 compared to 2016, 12% expect a 9.6% decline, and 24% foresee no change in revenue. This yields an overall averag...

Readmore

Labor Secretary Pushes Public-Private Apprenticeships

1 DAY AGO

Speaking at the G-20 labor and employment ministers' meeting on May 19, U.S. Secretary of Labor Alexander Acosta emphasized his support for fostering the growth of apprenticeships, a major priority for President Trump and the Department of Labor. The secretary's remarks reinforce the U.S.’s comm...

Readmore

Indices that Measure Water Scaling

materials_q_and_a_graphicQ: Why do my carbon steel valves and piping corrode when the Langlier index says they shouldn’t?

 

A: There are a variety of indexes that measure the scaling ­tendency of water and the Langlier index is probably one of the more recognized and utilized. Notice I said that the index measures the scaling tendency of water, so there is really no direct correlation between the Langlier index and any of the other indices to the actual corrosion rate of steel in water. The belief that these indexes determine the corrosivity of water stems from the assumption that a scale-forming water will be protective to carbon steel whereas a non-scaling water will be corrosive.

 

Water’s Scaling Tendencies

Many people assume that water is not very corrosive but a water’s chemistry can vary considerably, and depending on its given chemistry it can be very corrosive to cast iron and carbon steel. In addition to corrosion another issue associated with a water’s tendency to cause scaling is its affect on a heat exchanger’s efficiency.

To determine a water’s scaling tendency, several indices or formulas have been developed over the years, with each considering different variables of a water’s chemistry. The more common indexes are the Langlier Saturation Index (LSI), the Ryznar Stability Index (RSI) and the Puckorious Scaling Index (PSI)... and, no, I am not making up these names! The following will explain how each of is determined.

LSI = pH – pHs

The LSI index, developed by Dr. Langlier in 1936, considers factors of a water’s tendency to be in equilibrium with calcium carbonate. Calcium carbonate is just one of many minerals or elements that can be found in water and is the one responsible for forming calcareous deposits. The LSI considers the effects of calcium, total alkalinity, dissolved solids and temperature to arrive at a computed pH shown as pHs in the formula. Determining pHs manually is mathematically onerous, but fortunately there are websites that let you plug in the water chemistry and then pHs is calculated for you. Once pHs is known, simply subtract it from the water’s actual pH and if the result is positive then the water will be scaling; conversely, if the number is negative the water will tend to dissolve calcium carbonate.

RSI = 2 pHs – pH

John Ryznar developed a modification of the Langlier index in 1944 upon realizing that it was possible for both low- and high-hardness waters to have the same LSI. By reversing the placement of pH and pHs in the formula the RSI always results in a positive number. The pHs for the RSI is determined by the actual pH and the concentration of the calcium and bicarbonate ions, total dissolved solids and temperature. This calculation for pHs can also be found on the web so you just have to plug in the appropriate variables to determine pHs. A RSI less than 5 should be scaling, whereas a RSI above 7 will produce little, if any, scale.

PSI = 2pHs – pHeq

The next improvement of the scaling index was developed by Paul Puckorius. The Puckorius Scaling Index is also called the Practical Scaling Index, which I suppose makes it sound a little more credible! The PSI accounts for two additional variables that the other indices do not: the buffering capacity of water and the maximum quantity of precipitate that brings water to equilibrium. Therefore, the PSI uses an equilibrium pH rather than the actual pH to account for the buffering effect. The equilibrium pH (pHeq) = 1.465 log (M alkalinity) + 4.54. The numbers resulting from this formula are the same as the RSI index so a value less than 5 will be scaling and a number greater than 7 will result in little, if any, scaling.

Another Method to Control Scaling

One method used to control scaling is to lower the pH as this lowers a water’s alkalinity. So it is to be expected that a scaling index should account for this change, which the LSI and RSI do, but not the PSI. However, be careful in lowering the pH much below 6, because this will result in significant general corrosion of carbon steel and cast iron.

So which index is best to use?

Tests done for a variety of waters found that the LSI seemed to be more reliable in predicting scaling tendency, but there is no guarantee that scaling will or will not occur. Keep in mind these indices were never intended to be predictors of corrosion for carbon steel or cast iron but rather a tendency for water to develop scale or not. As much as we would like to have a simple formula to tell us whether a given water chemistry will be corrosive to steel, there are other variables—such as dissolved oxygen, chlorides and sulfate ions—that influence the corrosion of steel.


Thomas Spence is director of materials engineering for Flowserve Corp. (www.flowserve.com), Dayton, OH. Reach him at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

  • Latest Post

  • Popular

  • Links

  • Events

Advertisement

Looking for a career in the Valve Industry?

ValveCareers Horiz

To learn more, watch the videos below or visit ValveCareers.com a special initiative of the Valve Manufacturers Association