Safety-Relief Valve FAQ

Q:  How often should I test/ inspect my valve?

A: Maintenance should be performed on a regular basis. An initial inspection interval of no longer than 12 months is recommended. The user must establish an appropriate inspection interval depending on the service conditions, the condition of the valve and the level of performance desired.

The ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code does not require nor address testing installed valves. The only thing the code states are design and installation requirements, such as some valves must have a lifting lever. For instance for Section VIII:

“Each pressure relief valve on air, water over 140° F, or steam service shall have a substantial lifting device which when activated will release the seating force on the disk when the pressure relief valve is subjected to a pressure of at least 75% of the set pressure of the valve.”

Q: What mounting orientation should be used to install a safety valve?

A: Installing a safety valve in any position other than with the spindle vertical and upright may adversely affect performance and lifetime.

Q:  Why is there a hole in the valve body?

A: This drain hole is required on some models by the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code. It is intended to prevent any condensate from accumulating in the body that may freeze or corrode internal valve parts and prevent the valve from opening. The drain hole should be piped away to safely dispose of any discharge or condensate.

Q: Which end should be connected for vacuum valves?

A: This is often a confusing topic. The correct installation often looks backwards from what appears to be correct. A paper instruction tag illustrating the proper connection is attached to each valve. Vacuum valves should have the NPT threads that are cast integral to the body attached to the vacuum source. See the assembly drawing for additional clarification.

Q:  What set pressure should the valve be set to open?

A: Typically, the valve should be nameplate set to open at the MAWP (Maximum Allowable Working Pressure) of the vessel the valve is intended to protect. There is a tolerance to actual set pressure, which means a valve set at 100 psig nameplate may open slightly above or below 100 psig. Consult the current ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code for tolerance classes and special situations when the set pressure may be different than the MAWP.

Q:  Why is my valve leaking?

A: It is normal for spring-operated safety valves to exhibit leakage or simmer/warn, as the system operating pressure approaches the nameplate set pressure, typically in the 80%-90% range of nameplate set pressure. The ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code does not require a specific seat tightness requirement. A certain level of leakage is allowed per manufacturers’ literature and API-527 Seat Tightness Performance Standards, both of which can be found in the Technical Reference Catalog and in the Data Supplement, summarized as follows:

• Factory Standard Seat Tightness Performance: No visible (no audible for air service) leakage for 15 seconds (30 seconds for liquid or Section IV steam service) at 20% below nameplate set, or 5 psig below nameplate set, whichever is greater. EXCEPTION: Section IV steam service is checked at 12 psig.
• API-527 Standard Seat Tightness Performance: A Functional Test Report (FTR) is automatically provided for valves ordered to API-527. See API 527 for complete details.

At very low set pressures, the ratio of the downward spring force as compared to the upward pressure force is very small. In these cases it may be impossible to achieve seat tightness.

Use soft seats for superior seat tightness, assuming the application falls within the soft seat temperature limitations. Although soft seats will typically provide a higher degree of seat tightness than metal seats, Factory Standard does not ensure bubble-tight seats, regardless of seat material.

Q:  How high can my system pressure be before my valve opens?

A: Maintain a minimum operating gap of 10% between the system operating pressure and the safety valve’s nameplate set pressure. Since direct spring-operated safety valves may “simmer” or “warn” at 90% of the nameplate set pressure, and since the factory standard leak test is performed at 80% of nameplate set pressure, better seat tightness performance can be expected with an operating gap of 20%.

Q:  Why does my valve actuate/open early?

A: It may not be. Warn/simmer or seat leakage is sometimes mistaken for set pressure. Visible or audible leakage or system pressure drop is not set pressure. The correct definition of set pressure is:

• For steam or most valves in air/gas service, “pop” (an audible loud pop)
• For liquid service, first vertical steady stream
• For some valves in air/gas service (Models 230, 330, 330S, 333S, C776), first audible

Variance of set pressure is allowed, i.e., a Section VIII air valve with a nameplate of 100 psig set pressure may open from 97 psig to 103 psig, but will be factory set around 102 psig.

Gage issues may lead to incorrect reporting of set pressure. Ensure the gage is within calibration and is accurate for the pressure being measured. Rapid increases in system pressure (more than 2 psig/second, water hammer, reciprocating pumps) can make the valve appear to be opening early because the gage cannot accurately report the pressure to which the valve is exposed.

Q: Can I use a Section I steam valve in a Section VIII steam application?

A: Yes. Section I valves have more stringent setting blowdown requirements and may be used in Section VIII steam applications since they meet all the requirements as specified in Section VIII UG-125(a) “Pressure Relief Devices,” which states pressure relief devices must be “in accordance with the requirements of UG-125 through UG-137.” In addition, UG-125(b) actually specifies that even unfired steam boilers MUST use a Section I pressure relief device.

Q:  Does altitude affect set pressure?

A: No. Gage pressure (psig) is used to set valves so the effects of weather and altitude on set pressure can be ignored.

Q: Under what conditions may the lift lever or lifting device be omitted on Section VIII valves?

A:  Section VIII UG-136(a)(3) states, “Each pressure relief valve on air, water over 140° F (60° C), or steam service shall have a substantial lifting device which when activated will release the seating force on the disk when the pressure relief valve is subjected to a pressure of at least 75% of the set pressure of the valve.”

Code Case 2203 states the lifting device may be omitted provided:

• The user has a documented procedure and an associated implementation program for the periodic removal of the pressure relief valves for inspection and testing, and repair as necessary.
• The omission is specified by the user.
• The user shall obtain permission to omit the lifting device from the authority having jurisdiction over the installation of pressure vessels.

Q:  How does back pressure affect valve set pressure and capacity?

A: Back pressure reduces set pressure on a one-to-one basis, i.e., a valve set at 100 psig subjected to a backpressure at the outlet of 10 psig will not actuate until system pressure reaches 110 psig. Back pressure drastically reduces capacity; typically backpressure of 10% of set pressure will decrease capacity by 50%. Specific capacity reduction should be determined by the user on a case-by-case basis by flow testing. Back pressure in excess of 10% of set pressure is not recommended.

Q: What is the blowdown of a Section VIII or non-code safety valve?

A: The ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code does not have blowdown requirements for Section VIII (or non-code) valves. Blowdown may vary from less than 2% to more than 50%, depending on many factors including: valve design, dimensional tolerance variation, where the set pressure falls in the set pressure range of a spring, spring rate/force ratio, warn ring/guide settings, etc. Typical blowdown for most valves is 15% to 30%, but cannot be guaranteed.  VM

Jim Knox is president, Allied Valve, Inc. (www.alliedvalve.com), a valve repair service company and supplier of Tyco Kunkle and Dresser Consolidated safety valves in the Midwest. Reach him at knoxj@alliedvalveinc.com.